Generic filters
Filter by Practice Category
Filter by Practice Industry Category

Before You Fund a Private Mortgage: What Ontario Lenders Should Check

January is a busy month for private lenders. Mortgages that matured over the holidays need to be renewed or paid out, and borrowers start lining up financing ahead of the spring market.

Private lending can be a good use of capital, and the property gives the lender security that an unsecured loan doesn’t. But that security is only as good as the work done before the money goes out. Many of the problems we see in mortgage enforcement can be traced back to something that could have been caught before funding: a borrower who wasn’t who they said they were, a debt on title nobody noticed, or a term in the mortgage that turned out to be unenforceable.

Before you advance funds on a private mortgage, these are the questions worth answering.

Who Is the Borrower?

Mortgage fraud in Ontario often starts with identity. Someone poses as the registered owner of a property, often a property with no mortgage on it or one whose owner lives abroad, and borrows against it. When the real owner discovers what happened, the lender can be left holding a mortgage that may be set aside.

The borrower’s identity should be verified properly, and it should match the name on title. Be cautious when a deal is unusually urgent, when the borrower only wants to deal remotely or through an intermediary, or when the property was transferred recently for little or no money.

If the property is a matrimonial home, the borrower’s married spouse generally has to consent to the mortgage, even if the spouse isn’t on title. A mortgage registered without that consent can be challenged.

If the borrower is a corporation, confirm that it exists, that it is in good standing and that the people signing have authority to bind it. A personal guarantee from the principals is common and should be prepared and signed as carefully as the mortgage itself.

What Does Title Show?

A title search tells you what is already registered against the property, and where your mortgage will rank.

If you are lending in second or third position, every mortgage ahead of yours gets paid first on a sale. You should know the balance owing on each of them, whether they are in good standing and when they mature. A first mortgage that comes due a month after you fund can force a refinancing or a sale on terms you don’t control.

The search should also turn up construction liens, executions against the owner, and notices or other registrations that could affect value or priority. Unpaid property taxes don’t always appear on title, but the municipality’s claim for them ranks ahead of your mortgage, so a tax certificate is worth obtaining.

Title insurance for the lender can cover some of these risks, including certain kinds of fraud. It belongs alongside the searches and is often worth the cost. Read the policy’s terms, though: some lender policies limit fraud coverage on private mortgages unless the funds are paid directly to the registered owner or other approved parties. Our article on title, ownership and risk in Ontario real estate covers the basics of how title works.

Is the Property Worth What You Think?

Private lenders usually decide how much to advance based on loan-to-value. That number is only reliable if the value is.

An independent appraisal from an appraiser you choose, or at least one you have vetted, is far safer than relying on a figure from the borrower or a recent listing price. For a property in poor condition or an unusual location, it is worth asking how quickly it could realistically be sold if you had to enforce.

The property also has to stay insured for as long as the mortgage is outstanding, with the lender named on the policy as mortgagee. If the building burns down and the policy has lapsed, or you were never added to it, the land alone may not cover the debt.

Are the Terms Enforceable?

A mortgage can be well secured and still contain terms a court won’t enforce.

The most serious risk is the criminal rate of interest. Since January 1, 2025, charging more than 35% a year, calculated as an annual percentage rate, is a criminal offence for most loans. The calculation includes lender fees, bonuses and certain other charges as well as the stated interest rate, so a short-term loan with a modest rate and a large lender fee can cross the line. Some commercial loans to corporations are exempt or have a higher limit, but only if the loan meets the specific conditions. Our guide to the criminal rate of interest for Ontario mortgages explains how the calculation works.

Lenders also can’t charge a higher interest rate on arrears than on the rest of the loan. A clause that jumps the rate after a missed payment is likely to be unenforceable, although reasonable administration fees and costs may be treated differently.

It is better to find a problem with the terms before funding than to discover it when the borrower’s lawyer raises it in response to a demand for payment.

Renewing an Existing Mortgage?

A renewal can feel like paperwork, especially with a borrower you have dealt with before. It is still a good time to check a few things.

A fresh title search will show whether anything new has been registered since you funded, such as another mortgage, a lien or an execution. Property taxes and insurance should be confirmed as paid and current. And any change in the rate, fees or term should be documented in a written renewal agreement, with the criminal rate calculation done again on the new numbers.

If the borrower was behind during the last term, think carefully before renewing on the same terms. Our article on what happens when a mortgage goes into default explains the options available to lenders if things go wrong.

How Levy Zavet Lawyers Can Help

At Levy Zavet, our private mortgage lawyers act for private lenders and mortgage investment corporations, and have helped fund deals from $20,000 to $30 million. A lawyer handles each file, not just a clerk: verifying the borrower, searching title, reviewing your commitment, drafting enforceable terms and checking the interest calculation before any money goes out. If a loan later goes into default, our mortgage enforcement team handles demands, power of sale and recovery, so the firm that closed your mortgage is the one enforcing it.

If you have a mortgage maturing this winter or a new deal on the table, send us the commitment before you fund. We will tell you what title shows, whether the terms will hold up and what needs to change.

Book a free consultation or call us to discuss your next advance.

Levy Zavet PC

416-777-2244 | Toll-Free 1-877-777-8977

levyzavet.com

 

 

Articles